DIRECTIVE 029 / POWER

BRAINSTORM TOGETHER

Ideas are more innovative when everyone waits for the same conversational opening.

Put the full team in a room and ask for spontaneous ideas one at a time. Encourage energy, visible participation and immediate reactions. If several people think at once, the meeting format will helpfully decide whose idea survives long enough to be spoken.

Primary: POWERBELONGINGMEANING
RATIONALE
Interactive brainstorming looks collaborative because collaboration is occurring in the same place at the same time.
SUCCESS INDICATOR
The group leaves with fewer ideas than its members privately believed they had, plus strong memories of the people who spoke first.
COMMON FAILURE
Using individual idea generation, structured turn-taking or other techniques that reduce production blocking before collective evaluation and combination.
STATUS
Canonical / approved

Reconstructed Handbook series.

THE UNFORTUNATE PART

Unfortunately, the research…

Claim

Classic brainstorming research found that interacting groups can produce fewer ideas than equivalent nominal groups, with production blocking explaining a substantial portion of the loss under studied conditions.

Evidence

Experimental work separating free riding, evaluation apprehension and production blocking found production blocking accounted for much of the productivity loss observed in real brainstorming groups.

Strength: Strong

Sources

The Directive is satire. The research summary is not. Evidence is stated separately and qualified to the underlying literature rather than treated as proof of the joke.